Quick Answer: Google, Meta and TikTok sued California to block Assembly Bill 1709, a California social media law that bars platforms from giving teens and young children features like autoplay and recommended content displays. The companies argue the law violates their First Amendment free speech rights and conflicts with Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. The law is set to take effect on January 1.

Another week, another lawsuit between Big Tech and the state of California. This time the stakes are specific: which features a platform can show a 15-year-old when a parent has already said yes. As The Star reported, the case goes well beyond one feature. It could decide how much control states get over the feeds that billions of people see every day.

What AB 1709 Actually Restricts

AB 1709, introduced by Assembly member Josh Lowenthal, D-Long Beach, targets social media companies that serve children under 16. It bars platforms from providing addictive features such as autoplay and recommended content displays to teenagers and young children. The rationale is the one Lowenthal gave publicly: he cited anxiety and depression among children who grew up with constant access to phones, tablets and computers. He called the addictive nature of these features "harmful, full stop," and said they aren't appropriate for the developing brain.

Here's what matters for product teams: the law targets specific design patterns, not just content. Autoplay and algorithmic recommendations are the mechanics that keep someone watching after they've meant to stop. That focus is narrower than a blanket ban, but it reaches into the core of how most feeds work.

Why the Companies Are Suing: Free Speech and Section 230

Meta, Google and YouTube filed in the Northern District of California. TikTok filed in the Central District. Each company made two main arguments.

  1. First Amendment free speech. The companies say the state can't dictate how they arrange third-party posts. Meta's attorneys wrote that California wants to "appoint the State as the editor, curator and controller of online speech." In their view, ranking and recommending posts is editorial judgment, and that judgment is protected.
  2. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. This federal provision generally shields online platforms from being held liable for content posted by their users. The companies argue that a rule penalizing how they display that content effectively reaches back into the territory Section 230 protects.

The First Amendment argument has real legal history behind it. Courts have repeatedly treated the curation of user content as expressive activity. That doesn't guarantee a win for the companies, though. States argue that a law regulating design and product mechanics, rather than the content itself, deserves a different analysis. Expect this distinction to be central.

Most people assume that if a parent opts in, the feature is fine. That's the lazy reading, and TikTok's filing challenges it directly.

TikTok's attorneys described a parent who linked her account to her 15-year-old's through Family Pairing, set a 30-minute daily screen limit, enabled Restricted Mode, and decided that a personalized For You feed introducing her daughter to new musicians and science educators was appropriate. Under TikTok's reading of AB 1709, that parent "has no ability under California law to make that choice." The filing adds that the teen "does not have any say in her online expression" either.

This is the counter-intuitive finding that matters most. Parental consent controls in many state laws are the policy's pressure valve. If AB 1709 blocks features regardless of consent, it moves the decision away from families entirely. Whether you think that's protection or paternalism depends on your view of parental authority, but the consequence is concrete: a family's chosen configuration can be overridden by statute.

How AB 1709 Compares to SB 976

AB 1709 isn't the first attempt. Meta and others sued last year over Senate Bill 976, the "Protecting Our Kids from Social Media Addiction Act." The two laws overlap but differ in a way that matters for compliance.

FeatureSB 976AB 1709
Core restrictionBars addictive feeds and certain features to minorsBars autoplay and recommended content displays for teens and young children
Parental consentFeatures restricted without parental consentTikTok argues consent does not unlock restricted features
Age focusMinorsChildren under 16
Effective dateJan 1Jan 1
Lawsuit venue (as filed)Challenged earlier; 9th Circuit arguments expected next springMeta and Google in N.D. Cal.; TikTok in C.D. Cal.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals will likely hear arguments on SB 976 next spring, according to Courthouse News Services. That ruling could shape how judges read AB 1709, so the two cases are worth tracking together.

Why California Is Pushing Harder

These lawsuits didn't come from nowhere. California was among dozens of states that sued Meta in 2023, alleging the company designed harmful, addictive features to hook children while misleading the public about the risks. Those harms included depression, anxiety, addiction and body image issues tied to social comparison.

That case ended in a major payout. Meta agreed to pay up to US$17bn and change Facebook and Instagram, including hiding likes and reactions, blocking teens from extreme makeup filters, setting a default two-hour daily time limit that teens can only turn off with parental permission, muting notifications during school hours, and enabling a night mode that blocks the apps from midnight to 6am.

Private litigation is adding pressure too. In March, a Los Angeles jury found that Instagram and YouTube were responsible for the suffering of a 20-year-old Chico woman who argued the platforms were addictive by design. She was awarded US$6mil in damages and said she became hooked on both apps in grade school. Most people stop here, but that verdict is the reason companies are now treating design-based liability as a live legal risk, not a theoretical one.

What This Means If You Build, Manage or Raise Kids on These Platforms

If you work on product, the practical question is which features are at risk on January 1. Autoplay and recommended feeds for under-16 users are the direct targets. Reworking those features now, rather than waiting for an injunction ruling, is a choice some teams will face. The trade-off is engagement: removing or softening these mechanics reduces time-on-platform, which is the metric most ad-supported products are built around.

If you're a parent, the lawsuits don't change the controls you can use today. Family Pairing, screen-time limits and Restricted Mode still exist. What's uncertain is whether the law will let those settings unlock features for your child. Check the settings on each app your teen uses, and don't assume a toggle means a feature is legally available to them.

The caveat is that this is a pending case. Preliminary rulings, appeals and possible amendments could change the picture before January 1. Companies also haven't stopped operating, and a court could block the law in part while letting other pieces stand. Treat the current status as unsettled.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is California's AB 1709 social media law?

AB 1709 is a California bill introduced by Assembly member Josh Lowenthal. It restricts social media companies from providing addictive features, such as autoplay and recommended content displays, to teenagers and children under 16. It is set to take effect on January 1, and Google, Meta and TikTok have sued to block it.

How do you stop autoplay on social media for kids in California?

Under AB 1709, platforms would be required to stop providing autoplay and recommended content displays to users under 16 in California. Until the law takes effect, use each app's built-in controls, such as Family Pairing on TikTok, daily screen limits and Restricted Mode. Those settings don't guarantee the feature is off for every minor.

Why are tech companies suing California over this law?

The companies argue the law violates their First Amendment rights, claiming ranking and recommending posts is editorial judgment. They also cite Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which generally shields platforms from liability for third-party content. Meta's attorneys said the law tries to make the state the "editor, curator and controller" of online speech.

According to TikTok's lawsuit, no. The company argues AB 1709 would block features like its personalized For You feed even when a parent has linked accounts, set screen limits and approved the feed. Whether a court agrees is an open question, and the outcome will shape how much weight parental consent carries in similar laws.

How is AB 1709 different from SB 976?

SB 976, the "Protecting Our Kids from Social Media Addiction Act," bars addictive feeds to minors without parental consent. TikTok argues AB 1709 goes further by overriding that consent framework. Both laws take effect January 1, and the 9th Circuit is expected to hear arguments on SB 976 next spring.

Google, Meta and TikTok are asking courts to decide how far California can go in shaping what young users see, and that decision will matter well beyond one state. If you run a product or raise a teen, pick one thing to check this week: open the teen account settings on the app your child uses most, and note which features are on by default and which your family's controls actually change. Pass this to someone who's wrestling with the same California social media law questions, and bring the results to your next product or family conversation.